What is a Three-Level Comprehension Guide?
A Three-Level Comprehension Guide is a reading strategy designed to support and extend students’ reading comprehension. It involves a series of statements about a text, some true and some false. Students are asked to agree or disagree and to justify their responses.
The statements are organised, as the name suggests, in three levels:
Level One: these statements involve literal comprehension, where students search for answers directly stated in the text. This is sometimes called ‘Reading on the lines’.
It was after dinner when Jack realised that his dog had disappeared. T/F
Dinosaurs lived about 150 million years ago. T/F
Level Two: these statements involve making inferences. Students use the information directly stated in the text and combine it with other information – either from the text or from their own knowledge and experience – in order to decide whether the statement is true or false. This is sometimes called ‘Reading between the lines’.
Sally thought that Jack should have taken better care of his dog. T/F
The Mesosaurus probably lived in the water. T/F
Level Three: these statements ask students to apply their understanding about the text. They use both the literal and inferential information to make generalisations, create responses, form an hypothesis, explore implications or form a point of view. This is sometimes called ‘Reading beyond the lines.’
Being a pet owner means that you need to be responsible. T/F
Dinosaurs are popular with children because there are so many different kinds. T/F
Why use Three-Level Comprehension Guide in the classroom?
A Three-Level Comprehension Guide not only caters for differentiation within your classroom but also promotes a deeper understanding of what comprehension is all about.
It helps students to
- move beyond a superficial reading of the text in order to extract more meaning
- understand the difference between literal and inferential meaning
- learn how to make inferences
- engage and interact with the text by using it as a basis for creating, hypothesising, generalising and discussing.
How can you create a Three-Level Comprehension Guide?
- First decide what it is that you want your students to read and understand about the text. Perhaps your focus is on the examination of characters and their motivations, or maybe you want students to understand the specific content of a non-fiction text. Either way, these are the ‘big picture’ understandings that you want your students to achieve.
- Write a series of statements, both true and false, about those big picture understandings. These will become your Level Three statements.
- Then write the Level One or literal statements. They should relate to the Level Three statements.
- Finally, look for inferences in the text and write statements about these.
How can you use a Three-Level Comprehension Guide in the classroom?
Have students work in groups to discuss and agree on the responses. Remind them that while the answers to the Level One statements are very clear, the answers to Levels Two and Three statements might not be so definite. And that this is where their discussion and justification of their responses will be relevant.
Your observation of how students perform across the three levels of questions will provide you with information that you can use in a formative way.